Manual of Surgery Volume II Part 18

The cartilages enjoy a limited range of movement within the joint, pa.s.sing backwards during flexion, and forwards again when the limb is extended; under normal conditions the lateral moves more freely than the medial. While the limb is partly flexed, a slight degree of rotation of the leg at the knee is possible, and during this movement the cartilages glide from side to side, and the tibia rotates below them.

Any abnormal laxity of the ligaments of the joint may render the cartilages unduly mobile, so that they are liable to be displaced from comparatively slight causes, and when so displaced it is not uncommon for one or other to be torn by being nipped between the femur and the tibia. It is convenient to consider these "internal derangements of the knee-joint" separately, according to whether the meniscus is merely abnormally mobile, or is actually torn.

#Mobile Meniscus--Displacement of Medial Semilunar Cartilage# (Fig.

86).--The _medial_ meniscus exhibits undue mobility much more frequently than the lateral, and the condition is usually met with in adult males who engage in athletics, or who follow an employment which entails working in a kneeling or squatting position for long periods, with the toes turned outwards--for example, coal-miners. The tibial collateral ligament, and through it the coronary ligament, are thus gradually stretched, so that the cartilage becomes less securely anch.o.r.ed, and is rendered liable to be displaced towards the centre of the joint during some sudden movement which combines flexion of the knee with medial rotation of the femur upon the tibia, as, for example, in rising quickly from a squatting position, or turning rapidly and pus.h.i.+ng off with the foot, in the course of some game such as football or tennis. It may occur also from tripping on a loose stone or slipping off the kerbstone.

[Ill.u.s.tration: FIG. 86.--Diagram of Longitudinal Tear of Posterior End of Right Medial Semilunar Meniscus.]

What actually happens when the meniscus is displaced would appear to be, that the combined flexion and abduction of the knee opens up the medial side of the joint by separating the medial condyles of the femur and tibia, and that the medial meniscus in its movement backward during flexion slips under the femoral condyle and is caught between it and the tibia. It may even slip past the condyle and into the intercondyloid notch, and come to lie against the cruciate ligaments.

The mechanism by which this lesion is produced doubtless explains the greater frequency with which the _left_ knee is affected, as most sudden movements are made from right to left, thus throwing the strain upon the left knee.

_Clinical Features._--When seen immediately after the accident, the patient usually gives the history that while making a sudden movement he was seized with an intense sickening pain in the knee, accompanied, it may be, by a sensation of something giving way with a distinct crack, and followed by locking of the joint. He may fall to the ground and be unable to rise. On examination, the knee is found to be fixed in a slightly flexed position; and while the surgeon may be able to carry out movements of flexion to a considerable extent without increasing the pain, any attempt to extend the joint completely is extremely painful. Tenderness may be elicited on making pressure to the medial side of the ligamentum patellae in the groove between the femur and the tibia, but the meniscus cannot be recognised by palpation. Considerable effusion rapidly takes place into the synovial cavity.

The condition is liable to be mistaken for a sprain of the joint, particularly one implicating the tibial collateral ligament, but whereas in the lesion of the meniscus the maximum tenderness is in the interval _between_ the bones, in the sprain of the ligament the maximum tenderness is over its attachment to the bone, usually the tuberosity of the tibia.

_Treatment._--To reduce the displacement, the patient is placed on a couch, and, after the knee is fully flexed, the leg is rotated laterally and abducted, to separate the medial femoral condyle from the tibia, and while the rotation and abduction are maintained the leg is quickly extended. The return of the meniscus to its place is sometimes attended with a distinct snap, but in other cases reduction is only recognised to have taken place by the fact that the joint can be completely extended without causing pain.

Alternate flexion and extension combined with rotatory movements is sometimes successful. Several attempts are often necessary, and a general anaesthetic may be called for. After reduction, the limb is fixed with sand-bags, and ma.s.sage and movement are employed to get rid of effusion, care being taken that no rotatory movement at the knee is permitted. Rest and support are necessary to allow of repair of the torn ligaments, and when the patient begins to use the limb he must be careful to avoid movements which throw strain on the damaged ligaments.

In a considerable proportion of cases no recurrence takes place, and in the course of a month or two the patient is able to resume an active life with a perfectly useful joint. In other cases there is a tendency to recurrence of the displacement.

#Recurrent Displacement.#--In cases of recurrent displacement, each attack is accompanied by symptoms similar in kind to those above described, but less severe, and the patient usually learns to carry out some manipulation by which he is able to return the meniscus into position. He seeks advice with a view to having something done to prevent displacement occurring, and to restore the stability of the joint, which, in many cases, is impaired, preventing him following his occupation. There persists a variable amount of fluid in the joint, the ligaments are stretched and slack, and the quadriceps muscle is markedly wasted.

The symptoms closely resemble those of a "loose body," and it is often difficult to differentiate between them. In the case of a body free in the cavity of the joint, the site of the pain varies in different attacks, and the body can sometimes be palpated. Loose bodies wholly or partly composed of bone may be identified with the X-rays.

Attempts may be made to retain the meniscus in position by pads, bandages, or other forms of apparatus, so arranged as to prevent rotation and side-to-side movement at the knee. In the majority of cases, however, the best results are obtained by opening the joint and excising the meniscus in whole or in part, as may be necessary.

The limb is flexed on a splint until the wound has healed, after which ma.s.sage should be employed and movement of the joint commenced. At the end of two or three weeks the patient is allowed up, wearing an elastic bandage. In most cases the use of the joint is completely regained in from four to six weeks. As an indication of the perfect recovery of the functions of the joint after removal of the meniscus, professional football players are often able to resume their occupation.

#Displacement of the lateral meniscus# is comparatively rare. It is in every way comparable to displacement of the medial meniscus, and is treated on the same lines.

#Torn or Lacerated Meniscus.#--In a large proportion of cases of displaced meniscus in which the condition a.s.sumes the recurrent type, it is found, on opening the joint, that, in addition to being unduly mobile, the meniscus is torn or lacerated. The experience of surgeons varies regarding the nature of the laceration. In our experience the most common form is a longitudinal split, whereby a portion of the inner edge of the cartilage is separated from the rest and projects as a tag towards the centre of the joint (Fig. 86). As a rule, it is the anterior end that is torn, less frequently the posterior end.

Sometimes the meniscus is split from end to end, the outer crescent remaining in position, while the inner crescent pa.s.ses in between the condyles and lies curled up against the cruciate ligaments.

Occasionally the anterior end is torn from its attachment to the tibia, less frequently the posterior end. In one case we found the meniscus separated at both ends and lying between the bones and the capsule.

The _clinical features_ are similar to those of mobile meniscus with displacement, and as a rule the exact nature of the lesion is only discovered after opening the joint.

The _treatment_ consists in excising the loose tag or the whole meniscus, according to circ.u.mstances. The recovery of function is usually complete. It is not advisable to attempt to st.i.tch the torn portion in position.

#Rupture of the Cruciate Ligaments.#--A few cases have been recorded in which, as a result of severe twisting forms of violence, the cruciate ligaments have been torn from their attachments, leaving the joint loose and unstable, so that the tibia and the femur could be moved from side to side on one another. When the disability persists, the joint may be opened and the ligaments sutured in position (Mayo Robson).

#Sprains# of the knee are comparatively common as a result of sudden twisting or wrenching of the joint. In addition to the stretching or tearing of ligaments, there is usually a considerable effusion of fluid into the synovial cavity, and examination with the X-rays occasionally reveals that a portion of bone has been torn away with the ligament--_sprain-fracture_. The swelling fills up the hollows on either side of the patella, and extends for some distance in the synovial pouch underneath the quadriceps. The patella is raised from the front of the femur by the collection of fluid in the joint--"floating patella"--and, if firmly pressed upon, it may be made to rap against the trochlear surface.

A sprain is to be diagnosed from separation of one or other of the adjacent epiphyses, fracture involving the articular ends of the bones, and displacement of the semilunar menisci. On account of the swelling, which obscures the outline of the part, the differential diagnosis is often difficult, but as the swelling goes down under ma.s.sage it becomes easier. Chief reliance is to be placed upon the bony points retaining their normal relations.h.i.+ps, and upon the fact that the points of maximum tenderness are over the attachments of one or other of the collateral ligaments. As the tibial collateral ligament suffers most frequently, the most tender spot is usually over its attachment to the medial aspect of the head of the tibia--less frequently over the medial condyle of the femur.

Unless efficiently treated, a sprain of the knee is liable to result in weakness and instability of the joint from stretching of the ligaments, and this is often a.s.sociated with effusion of fluid in the synovial cavity (_traumatic hydrops_). This is more likely to occur if the joint is repeatedly subjected to slight degrees of violence, such as are liable to occur in football or other athletic exercises--hence the name "footballer's knee" sometimes applied to the condition.

A further cause of disability, following upon sprains of the knee, is _wasting of the quadriceps muscle_. The stability of the joint, whenever the position of full extension has been departed from, is largely dependent upon its capacity of controlling the amount of flexion, notably in descending a stair or in walking on uneven ground, hence it is that with a wasted quadriceps there is increasing liability to a repet.i.tion of the sprain. With each repet.i.tion of the sprain, there is an addition to the fluid in the joint, stretching of ligaments, and further wasting of the quadriceps. A form of vicious circle is established in which there is at the same time increased liability to sprain and diminished capacity of recovering from it.

Even after the repair of the damaged ligament or the removal of the mobile or torn meniscus, wasting of the quadriceps remains a source of weakness and disability and calls for treatment by ma.s.sage and electricity.

_Treatment._--In recent and severe cases the patient must be confined to bed, and firm pressure applied over the joint by means of cotton wool and a bandage. This may be removed once or twice a day to admit of the joint being douched, and at the same time it should be ma.s.saged and moved to promote absorption of the effusion and prevent the formation of adhesions.

Chronic effusion into the joint is most rapidly got rid of by rest and blistering. If the patient is unable to lie up, ma.s.sage should be systematically employed, and a firm elastic bandage worn. A patient who has once had a severe sprain of the knee, or who has developed the condition of "footballer's knee," must give up violent forms of exercise which expose him to further injuries, otherwise the condition is liable to be aggravated and to result in permanent impairment of the stability of the joint.

INJURIES OF THE PATELLA

#Fracture of the patella# is a comparatively common injury in adult males. Most frequently it is due to _muscular action_ the patella being snapped across the lower end of the femur by a sudden and forcible contraction of the quadriceps extensor muscle while the limb is partly flexed--as, for example, in the attempt to avoid falling backward. The bone is then broken as one breaks a stick by bending it across the knee, and the line of fracture, which is transverse or slightly oblique, crosses the bone a little below its middle.

Fractures produced in this way are almost never compound.

[Ill.u.s.tration: FIG. 87.--Radiogram of Fracture of Patella.]

The degree of displacement of the fragments depends upon the extent to which the expansion of the quadriceps tendon is lacerated. As a rule, it is but slightly torn, so that the separation of the fragments does not exceed an inch. In other cases it is widely torn, and the contraction of the quadriceps muscle is then able to separate the fragments by three or four inches, and sometimes causes tilting of the upper fragment. The blood effused into the joint tends still further to increase the separation. As the periosteum is usually torn at a level lower than the fracture, its free margin hangs as a fringe from the proximal fragment, and by getting between the broken ends may form a barrier to osseous union (Macewen).

_Clinical Features._--Immediately the bone breaks, the patient falls, and he is unable to rise again, as the limb is at once rendered useless, and in attempting to do so we have known him to fracture the patella of the other limb. The power of extending the limb is lost, and the patient is unable to lift his foot off the ground. The knee-joint is filled with blood and synovia, which usually extend into the bursa under the quadriceps. The two fragments can be detected, separated by an interval which admits of the finger being placed between them, and which is increased on flexing the knee. On relaxing the quadriceps, the fragments may be approximated more or less completely.

_Prognosis._--In cases with little displacement, if the fragments have been kept in perfect apposition, osseous union may take place, but in the great majority of cases the union is fibrous. The shortening of the quadriceps and the gradual stretching and thinning of the connecting fibrous band may allow of further separation of the fragments (Fig. 88), which to a variable extent interferes with the stability and functions of the limb. The proximal fragment sometimes becomes attached to the front of the femur, and moves with it, and the fibrous band between the two fragments gradually becomes stretched.

After bony union has occurred, it is not uncommon for the patella to be fractured again by a fall within a month or two of the original accident.

[Ill.u.s.tration: FIG. 88.--Fracture of Patella, showing wide separation of fragments, which are united by a fibrous band.

(Anatomical Museum of the University of Edinburgh.)]

_Treatment._--It is probably true that the best functional results are most speedily obtained by operative measures. The laceration of the aponeurosis of the quadriceps, the tilting of the fragments, and the interposition of the torn periosteum between them, can in no other way be rectified with certainty. The operation, however, should only be undertaken by those who are familiar with wound technique, and who have the means at their disposal for carrying it out. Operative treatment is specially indicated in young subjects who lead an active life, and in labouring men, particularly those who follow dangerous employments necessitating stability of the knee.

As soon as the wound is healed,--in a week or ten days,--ma.s.sage and movement of the limb are commenced, and the patient is encouraged to move his limb in bed. At the end of another week he may be allowed up with sticks or crutches.

_Non-operative Treatment._--In the majority of cases occurring in patients who do not follow a laborious occupation or otherwise lead an active life, a satisfactory result can be obtained without having recourse to operation. We have reason to be satisfied with the following method: the patient is kept in bed for a few days, the injured region being supported on a pillow and ma.s.saged daily, and the patella moved from side to side as a whole to prevent adhesion to the femur. About the fourth day he is allowed to get about with crutches.

As osseous union of the fragments is not essential to a good functional result, and as fibrous union does not necessarily entail any material interference with the usefulness of the limb, no attempt need be made to approximate the fragments, but every effort must be made to maintain the function of the quadriceps muscle and the mobility of the joint.

If it is desired to bring the fragments into contact and to secure osseous union, the limb should be placed upon an inclined plane to relax the quadriceps muscle, and means taken to arrest effusion and to diminish the swelling by systematic ma.s.sage and a supporting bandage.

When, in the course of a few days, this has been accomplished, the attempt is made to approximate the fragments, by fixing a large horseshoe-shaped piece of adhesive plaster to the front of the thigh, embracing the proximal fragment. Extension is made upon this by means of rubber tubing, which is fixed to the foot-piece of the splint. The bandage which binds the limb to the splint should make upward pressure on the distal fragment, or this may be done by a special piece of adhesive plaster with elastic tubing pulling in an upward direction.

The retentive apparatus is kept on for about three weeks, and a rigid, but easily removable, apparatus is thereafter applied, and the patient allowed up on crutches, the limb being ma.s.saged and exercised daily to improve the tone of the muscles.

When the fracture is caused by _direct violence_, such as a fall on the knee or the kick of a horse, it may be transverse, oblique, or vertical, but in many cases it is stellate, the bone being broken into several irregular pieces. These comminuted fractures are frequently compound. In transverse and oblique fractures, the displacement depends upon the same causes as in fracture by muscular action. In vertical and stellate fractures, unless the knee has been forcibly flexed after the bone has been broken, there is little or no displacement. The treatment is governed by the same considerations as in fractures by muscular action.

_Old-standing Fracture._--As fibrous union, even with an interval of several inches between the fragments, is not incompatible with a useful limb, it is not often necessary to operate for this condition, but when the usefulness of the limb is seriously impaired, operative treatment is indicated. The operation is carried out on the same lines as for recent fracture, the ends of the bones being rawed and adhesions divided. When the proximal fragment has become attached to the femur, it should be separated and a layer of fascia interposed; it is sometimes necessary to lengthen the quadriceps muscle by making a number of V-shaped incisions through its substance; or a flap may be turned down from the rectus and st.i.tched to the patella and the ligamentum patellae.

When operative treatment is contra-indicated, the patient should be fitted with a firm apparatus which will limit flexion of the knee and support the fragments.

#Dislocation of the patella# is rare. It results from exaggerated muscular movements when the limb is in the fully extended position, or from a blow on one or other edge of the bone. Laxity of the ligaments and knock-knee are predisposing factors. It is sometimes a.s.sociated with fracture of the edge of the trochlear surface, which renders retention in position difficult.

The _lateral_ is the most common variety--the _medial_ being rare.

Either may be complete or incomplete. Sometimes the bone is rotated so that its edge rests on the front of the femur--_vertical_ dislocation; and in a few cases it has been completely turned round, so that the articular surface is directed forwards.

_Clinical Features._--The joint is fixed, usually in a position of slight flexion, and the displaced patella can readily be palpated. The deformity is a striking one, and at first sight suggests a much more serious injury. Although easily reduced, the dislocation is liable to recur.