The Girls Of Murder City Part 12

Quinby wrote her column for more than fifty years, until her retirement in 1985 at the age of ninety-four.

By the summer of 1924, Genevieve Forbes could feel her status as the top "girl reporter" at the Tribune slipping away. Even after Maurine Watkins left the paper, Forbes's confidence never quite returned. Convinced she was failing on the women's crime beat, she declared in 1927, "Once upon a time, perhaps, there was a lovely lady behind the bars who told the story of her life more easily, honestly, and s.p.a.ciously to the woman reporter than to the man. But I've never met her." She argued that women in jail would much rather please a male reporter, despite "the stalwart a.s.surances of some lady reporters that they can get the 'woman angle' where masculine tactics fail."

Forbes met her future husband, fellow reporter John Herrick, while working on the Leopold-Loeb case, and in 1930 they moved to Was.h.i.+ngton, D.C., to cover politics. After World War II, she and Herrick turned to the theater, with little success, leaving her "more deeply and depressingly convinced than ever that I write badly."

W. W. O'Brien's greatest triumph came a year after Beulah Annan's acquittal, with the sensational "Millionaire Orphan" murder trial. He and William Scott Stewart won an acquittal for William D. Shepherd, who was accused of poisoning his wealthy young charge, Billy McClintock. O'Brien, along with his partner, was now one of the most prominent and sought-after defense attorneys in Chicago.

The following year, in 1926, O'Brien represented the bootlegger Joe Saltis, who faced a murder charge. Saltis was allied with Hymie Weiss, who had become Al Capone's greatest compet.i.tor and enemy. After jury selection for the case, O'Brien was walking with Weiss in front of the Holy Name Cathedral on North State Street when gunfire crackled above them. "You better lay down, Willie," the imperturbable Weiss told O'Brien. It was the last thing the gangster ever said. Weiss fell, a bullet in his forehead. O'Brien, wounded in the stomach, chest, and arm, survived, thanks to a two-inch-thick stack of folded papers in his inside coat pocket that kept a bullet from reaching his heart. O'Brien would win the Saltis case, but it proved to be his last major victory. He had begun drinking heavily, causing his wife to walk out on him. He and Stewart ended their partners.h.i.+p, and the big cases stopped coming his way.

In 1932, for reasons he never satisfactorily explained, O'Brien ran for governor of Illinois as an independent and received less than two thousand votes. Four years later, he was disbarred after he was caught trying to remove evidence from the state's attorney's office. The high-profile lawyer who had dazzled juries for years went to work as a salesman for the Midwest Exterminating Company. In 1939, in an attempt to regain his law license, he would testify that he had had "a mental collapse; that . . . he indulged in the use of intoxicating liquors to a considerable extent." He lost his teeth, and his heart started to give him trouble. He claimed that he had "no bank account and no money." In 1944, facing new legal troubles, he disappeared.

William Scott Stewart, like his former partner, also had difficulty holding on to success. In 1929, he was sentenced to three months in the county jail for contempt of court for attempting to prevent a state's witness from appearing in court. Two years later, he beat back a bar recommendation that he receive a one-year suspension for his role in a city corruption case.

Stewart defended gangsters through much of the 1930s, including Roger "the Terrible" Touhy, "Golf Bag" Sam Hunt, and Paul "the Waiter" Ricca. Working for the Mob took its toll. Stewart and his wife divorced in 1945, and he became estranged from his son and daughter. He died of a heart attack in 1964 at the age of seventy-four. The Tribune headlined its obituary "William Scott Stewart Dies Broke, Alone."

On June 16, 1924, Sabella Nitti was released on bail. She returned to her small farm in Stickney to await retrial, but the second trial never happened. On December 1, the state's attorney's office dropped the charges against her and her husband, Peter Crudelle.

One month after Sabella's release on bail, her lawyer, Helen Cirese, scored another unlikely victory: Lela Foster was acquitted of murder. The victory thrilled the young attorney as much as-maybe even more than-it did her client, and her law practice thrived. " 'The woman in law'-and straightaway one visualizes a stern, formidable, unromantic person, in a misplaced profession," Cirese wrote in a local women's magazine that November. She didn't consider herself misplaced at all, she insisted. "Have you ever seen the look of hopeless anxiety, of utter misery upon the face of an accused prisoner? Have you, then, seen the looks on that same face when twelve solemn men slowly file in and inform the court their verdict is 'Not Guilty'? The mingled joy, the relief, the moist eyes, the trembling lips, the simple words of thanks-that is truly romance-the romance of law."

After Revelry, Maurine Watkins never had another play produced on Broadway. In the three years after Chicago made her name, she saw a handful of her plays announced, and a couple even went into rehearsal, but none opened in the famed theater district. By the end of the 1920s, frustrated with New York, she moved to Los Angeles to pursue a screenwriting career.

In 1936 Maurine cowrote Libeled Lady, which starred Spencer Tracy, Jean Harlow, William Powell, and Myrna Loy. The screwball comedy revolves around a newspaper editor who convinces his girl to marry another man as a means of heading off a libel suit. It was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Picture. In 1981, seeking to revive interest in the movie, New York Times film critic Vincent Canby called it "magically funny" and "a comedy to rank alongside such cla.s.sics as Twentieth Century, To Be or Not to Be, Pat and Mike and The Awful Truth."

Canby was right, but Libeled Lady proved to be the exception in Maurine's short movie career. With Chicago, it turned out, she had said all she had to say about the American experience. The rest was pleasant busywork: straightforward comedies and melodramas that asked no more from an audience than that they show up. For a decade, she produced professionally crafted but uninspired screenplays for forgettable movies, such as No Man of Her Own, starring Clark Gable and Carole Lombard, and the Jimmy Durante vehicle Strictly Dynamite. Her last screen credit was for 1940's I Love You Again, which paired her story about a roguish amnesiac and his wife with Libeled Lady's Powell and Loy, this time in a misguided attempt to leech from the movie couple's burgeoning Thin Man popularity.

In 1942, fifteen years after Cecil B. DeMille's silent-movie version, Twentieth Century-Fox remade Chicago as a talking picture. Starring Ginger Rogers, Roxie Hart is a consistently entertaining movie, with a first-rate script by Nunnally Johnson and a naturalistic performance by Rogers. But it strayed a long way from the original play Maurine wrote. Most important of the changes: Rogers's Roxie didn't commit the crime. The Hays Code, which decreed that "no picture shall be produced that will lower the moral standards of those who see it," had come into effect, and so criminals could no longer get away with murder on-screen.

It was at about this time that Maurine quit screenwriting and moved to Florida to be near her retired parents. The move was apparently prompted by her father's poor health. Though she'd had some success publis.h.i.+ng short stories in the late twenties, she now effectively stopped writing. She devoted her later years to promoting and funding college scholars.h.i.+ps for Greek and Bible studies, and to refusing entreaties to turn Chicago into a stage musical. Maurine Watkins died of lung cancer in Jacksonville, Florida, in 1969, at age seventy-three. She never married.

Maurine's death, of course, was not the end of her story. Her family sold the rights to Chicago, and in 1975 a musical adaptation, conceived and directed by groundbreaking ch.o.r.eographer Bob Fosse, reached Broadway. Starring stage legends Gwen Verdon as Roxie and Chita Rivera as Velma, it ran for 936 performances and then went on tour. Twenty years later, the musical returned to the Great White Way, with Fosse's former lover and protegee Ann Reinking as Roxie. Newly relevant again, thanks to the O. J. Simpson and Amy Fisher trials, it took the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Musical and went on to become Broadway's longest-running revival ever. In 2002, Chicago: The Musical reached the big screen and won the Academy Award for Best Picture.

In the wake of the musical's mammoth success, a mystique of sorts swallowed Chicago's creator. Maurine Watkins, fans of the musical learned, fled Hollywood in the 1940s and lived out the rest of her life in obscurity, leaving her apartment only after consulting her horoscope. She repeatedly rejected producers' offers to buy her play's rights because she had become a born-again Christian and was horrified that in her youth she had contributed to the acquittals of two murderers and then celebrated them in a wink-and-nod Broadway smash.

This portrait of Maurine comes chiefly from Sheldon Abend, who was president of the American Play Company for more than three decades. Abend, who died in 2003, claimed that Maurine paid the company $500 per year expressly to refuse all offers to revive or adapt Chicago. "I believe this gal had a change of heart," Abend told the Chicago Tribune in 1997. "She didn't want to accept a dime from Chicago because she knew she did the wrong thing. She helped acquit a guilty person." Journalists and theater scholars recycled this view of Maurine for years. University of Delaware professor Thomas H. Pauly, in an introductory essay when Chicago was republished in 1997, described her as "an eccentric recluse and born-again Christian" in her later years and stated that she suffered from "a deep-seated guilt that her witty Chicago Tribune articles had been responsible for murderesses going free." Rob Marshall, director of the movie musical, also repeated the guilt-ridden, born-again Christian profile in interviews publicizing the movie's release.

It was all myth and misunderstanding. Abend, frustrated at being unable to cash in on one of his fallow properties and put off by her social reserve, reached the wrong conclusions about Maurine. She was never a born-again Christian; she was a practicing Christian for her entire life and a broadly curious theological thinker. In a 1959 letter to an administrator at Abilene Christian College, where she provided scholars.h.i.+p funds, she said that she had read religious texts "widely" and "wildly" throughout her life, "from Harnack's History of Dogma, Strong's Systematic Theology, and the Jesuits to Martin Buber's disciples and the 'literature' of the Mormons, etc., etc., etc. . . ."

As for having "helped acquit a guilty person," Maurine did no such thing, and there's no evidence to suggest she thought otherwise. Abend may have a.s.sumed she'd been a sob sister (it's unlikely he ever read her Tribune articles), but of course she wasn't. She never sentimentalized the alleged murderesses she covered, as Hearst's newspapers often did. In her articles for the Tribune in the spring and summer of 1924, she did everything she could to see Beulah and Belva convicted, sometimes pus.h.i.+ng the bounds of journalistic integrity in an effort to achieve her desired result.

It's possible that, after seeing the liberties taken with Chicago on film, Maurine rejected further adaptation offers because she just couldn't bear to have anyone else tinker with her sole successful play. Such reticence certainly would have made sense, especially after Roxie Hart turned Maurine's main character into a misunderstood innocent. She also may have been concerned that her play simply had become out-of-date. A 1935 stage revival in London received stinging reviews, with one critic declaring that it had "a flat monotony that produces only boredom and disgust."

That said, Maurine Watkins likely would have approved of the musical adaptation that she had spent more than a decade keeping out of theaters. Bob Fosse had no desire to stage, as he put it himself, "Mary Poppins at lunch in county jail." Unlike Abend, he understood exactly what Maurine was after with Chicago, and, finally able to move forward after her death, he stayed true to her desolate, relentlessly cynical spirit for the piece.

This is perhaps best exemplified at the close of the musical. The newly acquitted Roxie and Velma take to the vaudeville stage together, complete with glittery prop guns, working their notoriety for all it's worth. They launch into a lilting, self-congratulatory song-and-dance number. "You know, a lot of people have lost faith in America," Velma tells the audience. "But we are the living examples of what a wonderful country this is." She and Roxie then stride toward the audience, bathing in the applause of the packed house. "Thank you, thank you," they tell their adoring fans, but there's a hardened gloss to their smiles, a dark glint in their eyes. This is intentional. Fosse told his stars that, though Roxie and Velma are saying "Thank you, thank you" over and over, what they're thinking as the applause thunders down on them is, "f.u.c.k you, f.u.c.k you."

Acknowledgments.

Jim Donovan, my agent, believed in this book-and in me-from the very start. Without him, The Girls of Murder City never would have been written.

Alessandra Lusardi, my editor at Viking, expertly guided this book through every stage of its writing, shaping and fixing it as she went. Her contribution is incalculable.

Many others helped me in various ways during the researching and writing of The Girls of Murder City. They include Peter Bhatia, Jerry Casey, Joe Darrow, Nick Fox, Susan Gage, Al Girardi, Jeff Guinn, Aaron Lew, Michael Meggison, Marcia Melton, Maureen Ryan, Michael Walden, and Derek Zeller.

Jeanie Child, of the archives staff at the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Cook County, went beyond the call of duty on my behalf. I also received valuable a.s.sistance from Alan Gornick of the Western Springs Historical Society, Sarah Hutcheson of the Schlesinger Library at Harvard University's Radcliffe Inst.i.tute, Mollie Eblen and Barbara Grinnell of Transylvania University, and various staff members at the Harold Was.h.i.+ngton Library, the Chicago History Museum, the Illinois Supreme Court Archives, and the Illinois State Archives.

I would also like to convey my heartfelt appreciation to Wendy Teresi, Katherine Malm's great-granddaughter; Wayne d.i.c.kson and Ron d.i.c.kson, Ione Quinby's great-nephews; and Helen Del Messier Hachem, Helen Cirese's niece.

Finally, a special thank-you to my wife, Deborah King, for her keen editorial eye, her patient support, and of course her love.

Notes.

To tell the stories of Beulah Annan, Belva Gaertner, Maurine Watkins, and the rest of the women and men in these pages, I have relied on a broad swath of primary and secondary sources. (The books and journals used can be found listed in the bibliography.) I constructed many scenes using a combination of sources. Anything between quotation marks comes verbatim from a court transcript, police file, published article or book, personal letter, interview, or other cited source. Every action and event described in The Girls of Murder City is thoroughly grounded in doc.u.mented facts cited here.

The most significant sources of information for this book are the newspapers of the era. In Chicago in the 1920s, there were six daily newspapers, which competed aggressively with each other. The subjects are quoted frequently from newspaper interviews they gave and court testimony published in newspapers. To be sure, what a subject has to say in a contemporary newspaper story should not always be considered his or her exact words. The grammar was typically cleaned up and the phrasing sometimes "goosed" for dramatic effect by both reporters and rewrite men. That said, the city's "respectable" papers-the Tribune, the Daily News, the Daily Journal, and the Evening Post-took their journalistic ethics seriously. They did not just make stuff up. To b.u.t.tress accuracy, I leaned heavily on quotes and descriptions of events that appeared in more than one competing newspaper published on the same day. Newspapers were also a valuable source because they frequently published personal letters, diary entries, and various other primary source materials related to suspects and defendants.

While the reporters and rewrite men of the era did tend to overdramatize events compared to today's journalistic standards, in some ways crime reporting was more accurate in the 1920s. Police reporters were given extraordinary access that is unheard of today. They walked freely through police stations and jails at all hours, sat in on and partic.i.p.ated in police interrogations, played cards with prisoners in their cells. They investigated crimes themselves, trying to stay a step ahead of the police, and got so close to the action at crime scenes that they came home with blood on their shoes. They didn't get information from police spokesmen or press releases; they lived their beat.

In the notes for each chapter, after the first reference to a newspaper or magazine article, subsequent citations of the article omit the headline, except when two or more separate articles from the same issue of the same publication are cited in the chapter.

The following newspapers and library holdings are abbreviated throughout: CDJ = Chicago Daily Journal; CDN = Chicago Daily News; CDT = Chicago Daily Tribune; CEA = Chicago (Evening) American; CEP = Chicago Evening Post; CHE = Chicago Herald and Examiner; LAT = Los Angeles Times; NYT = New York Times; NYW = New York World.

Woollcott = Watkins, Maurine (1708-1712), letters to Alexander Woollcott; Correspondence: Woollcott, Alexander, 1887-1943, Houghton Library, Harvard College Library, Harvard University.

ISA: O'Brien = In the Matter of W. W. O'Brien (1939), Illinois State Archives, Supreme Court of Illinois, vault no. 48400-52602.

Note: In many instances, to make the notes more accessible and to save s.p.a.ce, multiple discrete citations for an event or scene have been pulled together into a larger group citation. To see the comprehensive, page-by-page source notes, along with supplementary research information, go to www.douglasperry.net.

Prologue.

1 The radio said so: "Mrs. Nitti Consoles Beulah: 'Lady Slayer' Told Not to Worry for 'Beauty Will Win,' " CEA, Apr. 5, 1924.

1 Beulah Annan peered through the bars: The cell number is given in CEA, Apr. 5, 1924.

1 But that was when she was the undisputed: "Beulah Annan Sobs Regret for Life She Took," CDT, Apr. 6, 1924.

1 Beulah never joined them: CEA, Apr. 5, 1924.

2 The next day, she sat sidesaddle: Chicago Daily News negatives collection, DN-0076751, Chicago History Museum.

2 This was the woman who: "Sleuths Sleuth on Sleuths in Domestic Row," CEP, Apr. 9, 1920; "Why the 'Cave-girl' Wants a Third Divorce From Hubby," Fres...o...b..e, Sept. 19, 1926.

2 "I'm feeling very well": "Never Threatened Law, Says Divorcee," CDN, Mar. 13, 1924.

2 Faith would see her through this ordeal: "Mrs. Gaertner Leads Jailed Women in Song," CDJ, Mar. 14, 1924.

3 "Here, Mrs. Gaertner": "Mrs. Gaertner Lies-Mrs. Law," CDJ, Mar. 13, 1924. CDN of the same day had Katherine Malm's quote slightly different: "Just pretend it's a beefsteak or a roast chicken, dearie. It makes it easy to swallow."

3 Then there was Mrs. Elizabeth Unkafer: "Jail Colony of Women in Chicago Grows," Danville (VA) Bee, Apr. 24, 1924.

3 And Mary Wezenak-"Moons.h.i.+ne Mary": "Woman on Trial For Moons.h.i.+ne Death," CDN, Mar. 11, 1924. Newspapers sometimes spelled her name "Wozemak."

3 After the police had trundled: "Feminism Leads Them to Kill, Dean Holds," Danville (VA) Bee, Apr. 17, 1924.

4 Motor cars were so plentiful: Aylesworth and Aylesworth, 25.

4 "I am staggered by this state of affairs": Sullivan, Rattling the Cup on Chicago Crime, 27.

4 Even Oak Park high school girls: "Mothers Fasten Oak Park Orgies Upon Vamp of 16," CDT, Jan. 26, 1923.

5 Belva, the "queen of the Loop cabarets": "Why the 'Cave-girl' Wants a Third Divorce From Hubby," Fres...o...b..e, Sept. 19, 1926.

5 And now that she had grown accustomed to "jail java": CEP photo caption, Mar. 13, 1924.

5 "How can they?": "Beulah Annan Sobs Regret for Life She Took," CDT, Apr. 6, 1924.

5 The bare stone walls: See Lane, Cook County Jail: Its Physical Characteristics and Living Conditions.

5 She took no food and confessed no more: CEA, Apr. 5, 1924.

6 At one point Sabella Nitti: Ibid.

6 "The writer who visits these prisoners week after week": Danville (VA) Bee, Apr. 24, 1924.

6 Once Beulah's wistful gaze: "What Life Finally Did to 'the Girl With the Man-Taming Eyes'," Hamilton (OH) Evening Journal, May 5, 1928; "Mrs. Annan Has Lonesome Day Behind the Bars," CDT, Apr. 7, 1924.

6 "Sorry? Who wouldn't be?": CEA, Apr. 5, 1924; also "Mrs. Annan Sorry She Won Race for Pistol," CDN, Apr. 5, 1924.

7 Beulah couldn't bear it: "False Colors of Bohemia Lead to Nowhere-Wanda Stopa Learns Too Late," CEA, Apr. 28, 1924.

7 "Another Chicago girl went gunning": Quinby, 216.

Chapter 1: A Grand Object Lesson.

11 Out in the hallway: Robert St. John, who started at the Chicago Daily News within weeks of Maurine Watkins joining the Tribune, noted that if you dared ask for a raise, your editor would tell you to go take a look at the "fifty or a hundred eager-looking young men and women" waiting out in the corridor every day, hoping to get a chance. "I can hire the best of them for ten dollars a week," the editor would say. See St. John's This Was My World, 175. This waiting ritual among wannabe reporters hadn't changed in a generation. In the early 1890s, Theodore Dreiser stood around in the halls of Chicago newspapers for hours at a time, day after day, hoping to be noticed or tapped for an a.s.signment on a busy day. See Dreiser's Newspaper Days, 45-47.

11 It was the first day of February: "Murder She Wrote: Tribune Reporter Maurine Watkins Achieved Her Greatest Fame with 'Chicago,' a Play Based on Two Sensational Local Crimes," CDT, July 16, 1997; "Women Who've Won: Maurine Watkins," Syracuse (NY) Herald, June 26, 1928.

11 The company had fifteen operators: WGN, 289-90.

12 The Tribune received hundreds of want-ad orders: For the paper's want-ad operation, see WGN, 180-85; Butcher, 109; Wendt, 365.

12 But Maurine, at twenty-seven years of age: Watkins, Maurine: Radcliffe College Student Files, 1890-1985, Radcliffe College Archives, Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe Inst.i.tute, Harvard University. On her graduate-school application, Watkins lists her birthday as July 27, 1896.

12 Its six stories rose up: WGN, 123. Austin Avenue is now Hubbard Street. After the straightening of the Chicago River, it no longer intersects with St. Clair.

12 Railroad tracks ran along: WGN, 102-3, 114, 124.

13 In front of it, facing Michigan Avenue: Wendt, 488.

13 "Most of them-the great ones-were ornate": Dreiser, 5-6.

14 The Tribune's local room hummed: WGN, 102.

14 Edward "Teddy" Beck was a Kansan: Butcher, 40-41; Rascoe, Before I Forget, 235.

14 She had written a letter: CDT, July 16, 1997. See Sullivan, Chicago Surrenders, 102, for more information on Robert Lee.

15 Most of the women who wanted to work: Ross, 543. Ross described Watkins's colleague at the Tribune, Maureen McKernan, as "large and commanding."

15 Maurine, on the other hand, was tiny: "Pistol Fire Lights Up 'Chicago'; or, Telling It to the Maurine," NYW, Jan. 16, 1927.

15 Her shyness was palpable: Syracuse (NY) Herald, June 26, 1928.

15 No, she had never been a reporter before: Ibid.

15 "Had any newspaper experience at all?": "The Author of 'Chicago,' " NYT, Jan. 2, 1927.

15 She was too frightened to answer: Syracuse (NY) Herald, June 26, 1928.

15 A Tribune reporter had famously tracked: Rascoe, Before I Forget, 233.